So here are the results of the very informal poll about what to do about Mif Albright. You all only voted once, right? And abided by the honor system that we all learned in grade school right?
- Keep it a Par 3 golf course 37%
- Open Space 29%
- All weather Athletic field 14%
- Dog Park 6%
- Other: 6%
- BMX Bike Park 3%
- Passive Park (trails, picnic and play areas) 3%
- Land swap with Ron Cowan 3%
- Turf Athletic field (soccer and football) 0%
The “other” recommendations were (1) sell the land for money (2) keep it in the public sphere and not give it away (3) JA’s idea. I had to do the other two from memory because something is all wonky with the poll widget. Speaking of polls, how do people feel about the polls. I would put a poll in here to gauge how people liked the polls, but thought that would be excessive.
I was thinking more about the whole Mif Albright question and again about the land swap thing with Ron Cowan. Right now, as it stands, there is no clear benefit for the City and its residents to allow the swap between the golf course land and the last Cowan parcel. Unless of course Cowan is willing to foot the entire capital costs for whatever the City decides it wants for the parcel. In that case, I could see a benefit, but in that case I say we ask for the most expensive thing, like the all weather turf fields. But if it’s just a straight land swap the City should say thanks, but no thanks.
Although, when I was thinking about alternative uses for the site and came up with another idea. Bear with me here folks. Recently some members of CASA came before the City Council to ask for a bit of land in a promiment place in Alameda (like in front of City Hall) to plant a small victory garden. While the Council wasn’t too keen about the idea of taking away the green space in front of City Hall, the idea was floated to possibly allow the group to use the old service station space across the street.
So, in addition to giving the group a prominent and visible space in Alameda, how about we allow them to cultivate a much bigger piece of land that will bring that space back to its roots (no pun intended). Bay Farm island used to be, well farm land, I think I recall someone saying that artichokes or some similiar veggie was grown on BFI. How poetic would it be to return a swath of to its original usage in a community garden of sorts that will benefit the City and those in the City that may not have land of their own to grow vegetables or fruit.
I remember when I was a young ‘un living in the Midwest, where there was plenty of land to spare, but the town I lived in set aside these community gardens for families, like ours, who didn’t have land to grow produce. All the City would need to do is provide the water and the community can do the rest.
Forget about percentages. How many votes were in each category?
Comment by Jack Richard — February 26, 2009 @ 8:15 am
I don’t think Lauren can see the numbers, can you, Lauren? Just ignore that poll altogether. Can’t believe they’d make it so easy to cheat.
I like the community garden idea (I hate astroturf fields for more reasons that I can list here). However, when I envisioned community gardens, I always thought the beltline property would be a better location, with the garden going lengthwise, where more people will have easy access to it who also have time to work it (just demographically seems better that way). I am in favor of open passive space for Mif, if that does not compromise the integrity and success of the golf course.
Comment by AD — February 26, 2009 @ 8:44 am
Jack R.: Unfortunately something went all weird with my access to the polls (which is why I had to write the “other” options by memory) so I can’t do the breakdown by actual votes. Sorry!
Comment by Lauren Do — February 26, 2009 @ 8:56 am
We could have our very own victory garden right here in Alameda!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_garden
Comment by alameda — February 26, 2009 @ 9:36 am
Unfortunately, the old gas station property is contaminated. This is why it just sits there.
If there was to be a garden, it would have to be above the ground, in tubs and such.
Perhaps not much of a Victory garden, but it could certainly be made useful and attractive.
I seem to remember Ms. Leto was interested at one point in showing people how they could “farm” in tubs… That would be an excellent use of an urban garden, teach wonderful skills to kids, and be a way for the city to model “greening.”
Was that in some old thread, or did I just dream that?
Good idea, though.
Comment by E T — February 26, 2009 @ 10:56 am
A community garden – great idea!
Comment by Jason — February 26, 2009 @ 11:05 am
I like the idea of the tub garden at the gas station. At least that site would be used for something. A few months ago, as part of the Slow Food festival, San Francisco had a vegetable garden set up in the park across the street from City Hall. It was quite beautiful.
As far as the 9 hole, please keep it a 9 hole. I am biased because I play golf, but for those who don’t, a 9 hole golf course allows non-golf people to experience the sport in a limited way. Also, 9 hole golf courses are where every child first plays. My daughter is 7 and I plan to get her started on golf this summer. Please don’t take that activity away from Alameda.
And the Ron Cowan land swap? Horrid. That idea confirms every paranoid thought I’ve had about the underlying motivations concerning privatization of Chuck Corica. All that BS about the City losing money was just that: BS.
Comment by Mike Rich — February 26, 2009 @ 11:07 am
ET: I think the folks from CASA were talking about all the plantings to be done above ground, like using hay bales to create containers.
Comment by Lauren Do — February 26, 2009 @ 12:29 pm
Great! I think it is a super idea!
Comment by E T — February 26, 2009 @ 3:54 pm
Community gardens are such a productive idea! I suggest we also learn how to catch and use rain water in the community gardens. Not being a golfer, I’m not sure how this would work: growing vegies and fruit trees around the perimeter of the Mif course by community gardeners.
There are many reasons why growing our food is beneficial. Just ask the youth at the Growing Youth Project! And in the coming years we may all wish we were growing food rather than lawns.
JA
Comment by J.A. Boyer — February 26, 2009 @ 6:00 pm
Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm. Farm farm farm. Farming farm. Farm a farm farm. Farm!
Comment by decoux — February 27, 2009 @ 3:31 pm
I love the container garden idea! I was passing by the site recently and thinking about what a shame it was that nothing has been done with the site. I love the retro look of the little building which could be spruced up and serve as a place for volunteers to manage the project. I got my garden supply catalog yesterday and it has all sorts of nifty solutions to growing things in small spaces (I’m tempted to try the upside down tomoato planters!)
Comment by Denise Shelton — February 28, 2009 @ 9:18 am